Understanding the Egyptian Uprising For Democracy, Report from the Ground

January 25 witnessed widespread street protests in Egypt. 90,000 Egyptians came out in seven main squares in Cairo while tens of thousands more came out in Alexandria, Mahalla, Suez, and several other Egyptian cities. The protests continue today in downtown Cairo as I write.

The popular uprising was first proposed on Facebook via the “We are all Khaled Said” page, a group with more than 400,000 members dedicated to the memory of Khaled Said, a young Egyptian activist from Alexandria who was brutally tortured and fatally beaten into a pulp by local police last year.

17 opposition groups, as well as a number of prominent intellectuals and celebrities officially endorsed and joined the uprising. The Muslim Brotherhood did not officially endorse the protests though members likely joined in their individual capacities.

Demands of the January 25 Uprising

After decades of autocratic rule, state propaganda, institutionalized government corruption, police brutality, and suppression of basic freedoms, frustrated Egyptians are taking to the streets seeking change and demanding democracy, dignity, and civic reforms.

The uprising made the following specific demands:

-          An increase of minimum wages in Egypt to 1200LE (US $200)

-          An end to the special emergency laws

-          An end to police brutality and the resignation of the minister of interior

-          A two term presidency  (never elected by the people, Mubarak has been in power for over 30 years)

-          Free and transparent elections

-          A government that represents the people, respects its citizenry and acts as a caretaker, not usurper, of Egyptian civil rights.

Government Response: defiance, violence, and attempts at sabotage

The uprising was organized and carried out by ordinary Egyptians from every walk of life as a non-partisan, non-ideological, peaceful push for reform. Yet the large number of protesters who at first were allowed to gather and chant with minimal police harassment were soon met with unprovoked violence by the massive droves of heavily armed security forces. Water hoses, more than 60 cannons of tear gas, rubber bullets, and even live ammunition according to some reports, were unleashed later in the day to disperse the crowds who had vowed an overnight sit-in at Cairo’s main downtown square, Tahrir Square.

Yesterday the government shut down Twitter. It disabled the country’s main three mobile networks in the downtown area where the protests were taking place to stifle communication between protesters. Today, it shutdown Facebook. There has been little objection from the US (more on that later).

From the state controlled media side, the response was equally predictable. For the most part Egyptian media tried hard to turn a blind eye to the protests in order to minimize their influence on audiences.  Egyptian radio, TV, and satellite dished out the usual diet of football, music, soap operas, and game shows, steering well away from any reports or analysis of the uprising. This morning’s newspaper headlines were also as predictable: the government blamed the uprising on its favorite arch-nemesis the Muslim Brotherhood (who neither organized nor endorsed the protests) and then dismissed the calls for reform as coming from “a bunch of clueless kids” (Muslim Brotherhood or clueless kids?)

View from the Streets

The thousands of mostly educated protesters seemed anything but a bunch of clueless kids. Virtually every segment of Egyptian life was represented: young and old, professionals and laborers, men and women, religious and secular, Muslim and Christian.

At its zenith, Cairo’s downtown protests reached 60,000 people. It began with a few thousand who were later reinforced by thousands more coming out of side streets and crossing bridges over the Nile. Despite the peaceful and civil nature of the protests that chanted the Egyptian anthem and slogans demanding democratic reforms, things started to get ugly.

Policemen in plain clothes and hired thugs were dispersed into the crowds to instigate chaos. They beat up protesters with sticks and chains while the security forces fired tear gas cannons, rubber bullets, and opened water hoses. Over the next few hours, much of the crowds dispersed. A few of the younger protesters responded by throwing rocks, burning police cars in at least two instances, and scuffling with soldiers.

Government propaganda claims that the protesters were agitators. This eyewitness account shows unarmed protesters being ganged up on by club-wielding security forces

The few thousand protesters who remained defiant took to the side streets and continued their chants while the experienced riot police closed off all the exits to the main roads. As we marched through the narrow streets of Souk el Balah and Sabteya, the chanting crowds urged people to come down and join. Despite the 3:00AM time, many did, with others applauding the marching crowd from their windows and balconies.

Women played leading roles in the protests; one could often hear a high-pitched voice chanting slogans followed by the crowds roaring the slogans back. “Egyptians come down now, march for your rights,” “Mubarak, enough is enough, resign now,” “No to dictatorship, yes to democracy,” “We demand respect and dignity,” “We are Egypt, we  will not remain silent anymore,” went some of the chants.

As we came up to a major security blockade with hundreds of lined-up soldiers in riot gear, the crowd came to a halt and deliberated which way to go. I decided to walk over to the police to have a chat. I asked the head police officer, rather tongue-in-cheek, “why are you blocking our way?” He ignored me and walked in the other direction while soldiers surrounded me and pushed me around. “This is a peaceful protest,“ I said, “it is the right of our citizens to express their demands peacefully on the streets when there is no other way,” I said to no avail. I sensed I had to walk back to the crowds before the soldiers got overly excited and let their fist and batons speak the only language they knew.

A few minutes after I had walked back, the files of soldiers started to march towards us, yelling a loud and coordinated “Hoo Haa” that echoed into the night. A few steps later, they begin to fire tear gas and rubber bullets. We ran down the street trying to avert the popping sounds by our feet and the smoke.  I had two close shaves.

The Significance of January 25

The January 25 uprising constituted the single largest day of popular uprising in Egypt in the 30 years of Mubarak’s dictatorship.  It showed that the people have a voice that can be directly expressed at a grassroots level without outside intervention. In the past, protests depended on a handful of strongmen for organization and guidance. It showed the government that Egyptians were finally willing to break the decades-long silence and fear, to take risks, and make sacrifices in order to claim what is rightfully theirs: a fighting chance at a dignified future.

Four people died and close to 100 were injured. The hope is that their sacrifices are not lost on the rest of Egyptians who need to keep the momentum pushing for an end to corruption and the dawn of a new day.

The Way Forward

Egyptians must recognize that while revolution may be obtained from the streets, true lasting reform never is. For that to happen, all Egyptians, government and people, must undergo a serious paradigm shift in the local political culture. It must be recognized that true reform is more about processes than personalities. Egyptians must move away from the personality cult, learning to accept that no single person is the problem and no single person is the solution, that exchanging one autocratic leader for another, or one autocratic party for another does nothing for the cause of freedom and reform.  We must recognize that we are all part of the problem and we are all part of the solution. For true reform to happen, Egyptians must change the system itself to ensure the following:

-          Constitutional reform that is entrusted to a fully independent supreme court whose judgment is binding

-          A true democratic multi-party system with free, transparent elections

-          The complete independence of the parliament and the judiciary from the executive branch

-          The supremacy of the rule of law

-          Fair and equal treatment of all citizens regardless of faith, gender, class, or ethnicity

-          A merit-based open free market of goods, services, and ideas

-          The end of exceptionalism, nepotism, and cronyism

For Egyptian protests to succeed, the following should be observed:

-          They must remain peaceful, non-ideological, non-partisan

-          They must remain open and inclusive of all Egyptians from all walks of life

-          They must remain hopeful with a focus on the future, on a fresh vision, and not vengeful with a focus on the past

-          They must remain focused objectively on the key demands for democracy and reform and not on a coup or a power grab or simply venting anger

-          They must galvanize wider audiences by tapping into the existing organized bodies like the actors guild (who would give good exposure and publicity) the football ultras (who would give great manpower) and the Friday prayers (that would help with logistics since large numbers are already gathered)

Between a Nightmare and a Dream

I spoke to an old man who works on a school bus by day and a taxi by night 7 days a week. Spend one hour in Cairo’s extreme traffic and you get a hint of how much this man suffers. What does he get in return? Less than $200 per month to feed his family of seven. I spoke to young men who have been looking for jobs for over six years, despite working hard to obtain their degrees.

Egyptians everywhere complain from the overbearing bureaucracy, the double standards that differentiate between the well-connected and the not-so-well-connected. Wages remain the same while prices, especially food, continue to sky rocket.

Businessmen connected to the government obtain land for “pennies,” they build apartment complexes where a single unit could average 1 million L.E. They make hundreds of millions while an increasing number of Egyptians live in squalid conditions unable to afford the basic costs of living.

Egyptians feel that their government has only one goal: to maintain power. It spends all its resources working towards that goal while neglecting planning and governance that benefit the people.

In the last parliamentary elections which were intensely rigged, the government’s ruling party supposedly won a whopping 97% of seats, despite the presence of a healthy and popular opposition.

And yet Egyptians remain hopeful.

“We believe in ourselves, we believe in Egypt. This government thinks it owns us, it thinks it owns the country. It does not. They are just rogue employees. We will have a government that truly represents the people, that truly answers to us, and when we do we will rise again,” said Nabil, an engineer.

“We dream of a day when we can invest our energy trying to reach our potential in science, the arts, sports, and culture, and not trying to fight oppression and simply survive. Egyptians know what we are capable of, we just want a chance to prove it to ourselves and to the world. We won’t rest until we see that day,” said Maryam, a protester.

Egyptians, it seems, just want to be competitors in the family of democratic nations.

Email, Print, Share: These icons link to social bookmarking sites where readers can share and discover new web pages.
  • email
  • Print
  • Facebook
  • TwitThis
  • LinkedIn
  • MySpace
  • Technorati
  • NewsVine
  • Digg
  • del.icio.us
  • StumbleUpon
  • Reddit
  • Bloglines
  • Wikio
  • Google Bookmarks
  • YahooBuzz
  • Live-MSN
  • Ask
  • Netscape
This entry was posted in On Politics and tagged , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

22 Responses to Understanding the Egyptian Uprising For Democracy, Report from the Ground

  1. MYT says:

    good stuff. be careful and ta7ya masr!

  2. Pingback: Tweets that mention Understanding the Egyptian Uprising, Report from the Ground | MindfulOfDreams.com -- Topsy.com

  3. Jerry says:

    Finally, someone is writting about this. I watch the news and they mention as if it was a filler word.

  4. Nadar says:

    A nice piece, and very informative. Keep it coming. I hope this will be a brighter future for Egypt.

  5. Hazem Bata says:

    Your analysis is spot on Ahmed. I will point out that the reason it has taken so long for the uprising to occur is because Egyptians are lackadaisical and have a high tolerance for discomfort. But it appears that has come to an end…

  6. Pingback: mg src=”http://www.ahmedrehab.com/images/bloglink3.jpg” border=”0″ style=”float:left”>Understanding the Egyptian Uprising For Democracy, Report from the Ground | Ahmed Rehab

  7. Bob says:

    I hope they succeed.

  8. mona says:

    Thank you for this.Some one sent it to me on fb. Yet, I have a few reservations, if I may. I want to ask you why do you assume that all the people want a democratic solution? I’m an Egyptian living in Cairo. Maybe I’m not one of them, but many people here think an Islamic system might be an option.

    The people are swept away with Tunisia and the Jasmin Revolution. And I think one of the charactiristics of a ‘revolution’ is not really having a clear vision yet, of what you want… you only know at that time what you don’t want. And I do believe this is the case of Egypt. We all agree on what we don’t want.

    The fact is that not any regime would work for Egypt. And the fact is Egypt is quite comfy with dictatorship… they know no other type. So, really what Egypt needs is a ‘nice’ dictator:)) Know any ‘nice’ dictators walking around? Well, not to that extreme, but maybe you get what I’m saying. Something like Malaysia.
    I am by no means a politician or know that much about politics, but I’m simply expressing some thoughts.

    But I very much agree with you on that businessmen paragraph. I was just commenting on that on Jezeerah on facebook (when it wasn’t blocked… now it’s back on). I believe and I’m convinced they are as much to blame, if not more, for the situation of the poor and the middle class. They make Mubarak almost seem like a nice guy! Almost!

    Sorry if I wrote too much, but hey! It’s a revo…

    Mona A. Ghani

    • Jose says:

      Hi Mona
      I like your comment and you are right even if I don’t know much about the regime there but I have my girl there so I’m worry
      Hope that’s going to work out
      Is my wish , Jose USA

  9. Hazem Bata says:

    Mona,

    I must say that democracy is the only system sanctioned by Islam. No where does Islam give one person (or group) the absolute right to rule others over the will of the others. To reject democracy is to accept authoritarianism…even “nice” authoritarianism.

    Furthermore, what is the case against democracy? Why would a rational human reject such freedoms? I don’t understand it.

    And finally, what is the “Islamic” system people talk about? It is yet to be defined by anyone. Is it a bunch of religious scholars making all decisions? Is it a khalifa? What is it?

    Thank you.

  10. Ahmed:

    Assalaamu Alaikum! Thank you for sharing this with us and keep the posts coming. I’m sharing your posts on my blog, on twitter and on Facebook. My best wishes and my prayers for peace, safety and freedom are with you all.

    Was’salaam,

    Junaid

  11. Johann P says:

    Best analysis I read so far, keep up the struggle for justice

  12. Lena t. says:

    Stay safe Ahmed and keep the reports coming. Your eyewitness accounts provide a perspective we dont get to see Here in the US.

  13. Alyaa says:

    Mona,

    Can I ask you what part of Egypt do you live in? I am only asking you that due to your comment. What I would like to say I agree with Ahmed about his article and I am happy to see someone writing about the truth of whats going on in Egypt at the moment and it is time for “True Protest”… Well this is regarding to everyone and not only you Mona but you brought up an important issue of “why do you assume that all the people want a democratic solution?”

    Enough of Mubarak and all he did to ruine the country in the past 30 years of his ruling.. Even though I lived in the USA all my life of his presence but every single time I go back to my home country I see Egypt becoming worse and worse. Have you watched Amr El Lasies (Wahed Men Elnas) show? That is enough to tell you how many people out there live in poverty and in a very bad situation almost close to being dead. In the states they have poverty but at least they have the governments help by giving money and also trying to find a job. Why do you think Sheikh El Shaarawy (may he rest in peace) said America is a “Muslim country without religion”. They use Islamic rules of humanity for its people and that is why he said that.

    Respecting humanity is a big thing. Who can survive these days with a minimum wage of 500 (or less) Egyptian pounds per month? I am sure that everyone will want a democratic government. I must say American government is not so democratic when it comes to some stuff but it sure is respecting its citizens and respecting humanity as Islam, Christianity, Juadisim, and all other religions say.

    Let me say that I am only presenting my thoughts as I am reading on since I lived in 2 different countries with opposite minds and thoughts.

    Thank you for your resepect and your time.

  14. Mulham says:

    Stand up Egypt for your basic human rights. Your government is corrupt and has not represented you for 30 plus years. Hosni Mubarak is a slave to Israel and America and it is about time the entire world realizes that you can have democracy and stability in the Middle East at the same time.

  15. Karen D. says:

    Ahmed, May God keep you safe and may the people of Egypt be successful in their quest for democracy and a better life for their children!

  16. Riyad says:

    Ahmed – thank you for a well written and thought out assessment. Inshallah we’ll see some real long term change. A reduction in widespread corruption will be particularly essential to prevent things from simply returning to the current state after things ‘blow over’.

    Hazem – I just wanted to address your question about an “Islamic” government. Although democracy is an important element, it is not the complete package. Ultimately, and Islamic government is one that is founded upon the rule of Allah (God), and then, in areas that Allah has not ruled on, one may have democracy – because ultimately, you can’t out-vote Allah. For example, alcohol has been prohibited by Allah – so you can never ‘vote’ to allow it, even if you have 100% in favor. However, for areas where the rule of Allah isn’t explicit, it can be voted upon within the limits of sharia.

  17. Bryn says:

    Ahmed – Thank you. This has given us a perspective of what is really going on on the ground in Egypt. I hope this can be resolved soon for the better.

    This question over what government should follow Mubarak after a successful revolution is interesting. Riyad mentioned Ijtihad(muslims have autonomy to make decisions where there is no precedent) and as there are only 270 of 6346 verses that deal with governance and policy(mostly, punishment), the field is open for any form of government, particularly with Shura(consultation) and Ijma(consensus) that are also mentioned in the Qu’ran. I recently read an article that claimed that Islam was the most democratic of the Abrahamic religions, very much like Sheikh El Shaarawy’s quote that Alyaa mentioned.

    Anyway, bettawfeeq Ahmed

    Bryn

  18. Christopher says:

    All the best wishes for the brave people facing the security apparatus .
    I hope that what will come out of this is an Egypt , free for all its citizens ,
    where the government is transparent , where nepotism is faced with public accountability , where freedom of speech is guaranteed , an Egypt that respects the human rights of all of its people , Muslim , Copt we are all Egyptian , and all feed up with the state of the country

  19. Pingback: Otro vídeo de lo que pasa en #Egipto #egypt de la protestas « La Sonrisa de los Cipreses

  20. Pingback: The Nuts and Bolts of Occupy Wall Street » Counterpunch: Tells the Facts, Names the Names

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

*

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>